META: Explore the benefits of remarketing vs. buybacks to optimize asset recovery, safeguard data security, and advance your company’s sustainability goals.

Remarketing vs. Buybacks: Key Differences in IT Asset Management

You just started a new position as the IT manager at a mid-size firm. Your predecessor left you with a sizable backlog of decommissioned hardware. The data stored on those retired devices renders them a potential security risk, so you can’t just toss them in the dumpster and be done with it. That’s also bad for the environment, and it runs counter to the company’s sustainability objectives. For now, those devices are just taking up space, and they’re losing value by the day.

It’s far from an ideal situation, but you see it as an opportunity. By working with the right partners, you can address your data security risks, free up storage space, and recapture some scarce funds for your IT budget. A reputable IT asset disposition (ITAD) company can destroy sensitive data on those devices, repair or refurbish them, and sell them.

The first step is to choose between remarketing vs. buybacks, two ITAD strategies enabling organizations to recover value, reduce their environmental impact, and improve financial performance. Remarketing maximizes the value you can return to the company’s bottom line, whereas buybacks provide immediate cash flow without the need for your ongoing involvement. Choosing the right strategy can depend on many factors, including the condition of your retired assets, financial objectives, and the availability of resources.

Here’s an overview of both approaches to help you decide which strategy is best for you.

Defining Remarketing in ITAM

In the context of IT Asset Management(ITAM), remarketing refers to the process of refurbishing and reselling decommissioned IT assets. The goal is to maximize financial returns and extend the lifecycle of devices such as servers, laptops, desktop computers, and mobile phones. Remarketing involves assessing, upgrading, and preparing used IT equipment to be resold on the secondary market.

The process starts with inspection and grading. To understand the value of a laptop, for example, you might begin with a visual inspection to assess its cosmetic condition. Without any major problems, such as cracked screens, the next step might be to power up the device to determine whether the system boots up, the keyboard and screen function properly, and so on. This inspection and grading process provides an early indication of the likely value of the device and the investment required to repair or refurbish it.

The next step is to erase or overwrite any data on the device permanently. ITAD companies have special equipment and well-defined processes for secure data destruction, including data wiping, hard-drive shredding, and degaussing. The device is then ready for refurbishment, which includes minor repairs, cosmetic clean-up, and a thorough battery of functional checks.

Finally, remarketing involves selling the device on secondary markets. Theoretically, this could include listing items on online auction sites, answering buyer questions, accepting bids, and shipping products to end-users. That’s a lot of work. Practically speaking, selling used IT devices via expert channels that understand the market and have strong connections to potential buyers is far more efficient.

ITAD service providers have strong relationships with brokers and other buyers who understand the market for used devices and have efficient processes for moving those devices through the secondary market.

Understanding Buybacks

A buyback involves selling IT assets directly to an ITAD service provider at a predetermined value, usually based on the equipment's age, condition, and brand. In this case, the ITAD company assumes all responsibility for the costs and risks of refurbishing and reselling the used devices. Buybacks are a fast and efficient way to liquidate equipment while eliminating the operational burdens associated with remarketing.

Buybacks offer another important benefit; they reduce waste and improve an organization’s sustainability metrics by guaranteeing that unwanted devices are reused or responsibly recycled.

With buybacks, an ITAD service provider assesses the value of retired assets based on their likely market value, considering the age of each device and its condition and brand. Based on that information, the ITAD company offers a lump-sum payment and takes ownership of the devices.

With buybacks, the ITAD vendor assumes full responsibility for asset disposition and the logistical complexities accompanying that process. Naturally, the originating company still wants a guarantee that the ITAD vendor will handle data security and environmentally responsible disposal. Reputable ITAD companies offer certificates of secure data destruction and sustainability reports backed by certifying organizations like SERI (R2), which perform routine audits to validate compliance with their rigorous standards.

Key Differences Between Remarketing and Buybacks

Remarketing and buybacks differ in several respects:

Revenue Potential: Remarketing generally yields higher top-line returns, but it takes longer to get those returns, and more company resources are required to complete the process. Remarketing also involves more risk because some devices may be non-functional or difficult to sell. Buy backs, in contrast, offer a guaranteed up-front payment.

Speed: Buybacks offer faster cash flow, making them a highly efficient option that delivers quick, predictable financial returns. Once the transfer of assets is complete, the ITAD vendor certifies that data destruction and responsible disposition have been completed.

Risk and Effort: While remarketing can yield higher returns, it also entails higher risk and requires substantially more in-house resources. Buybacks, in contrast, provide immediate cash flow with no risk and minimal effort.

Remarketing is often the preferred approach in cases where IT assets have a higher value and are likely to sell quickly. Buybacks are more suitable for older or lower-value assets, especially in cases where the total quantity of such devices is relatively high.

Here’s a side-by-side comparison to help you decide which strategy aligns best with your goals:

‍

‍

Best Practices for Remarketing or Buyback

If your organization has adequate internal resources to handle the remarketing process, you should assess the quality, age, and market value of your retired assets to determine whether this approach will likely yield high returns for your company.

Next, perform a high-level financial analysis, starting with your selling price and then subtracting your projected costs for repair, refurbishment, sales, and administration. Also, remember that your cash flow timeline will be longer in the case of remarketing vs. buybacks.

Throughout this process, working with vendors experienced in remarketing can be very helpful to maximize your overall value. Look for reputable, experienced ITAD vendors who understand the secondary IT device market and carry certifications such as R2.

Buybacks are usually a better approach for older or lower-value assets. Start by negotiating a lump-sum price for your assets based on factors such as age, condition, and brand. You can often get favorable rates for large volumes of retired devices.

You should also evaluate your ITAD vendor’s sustainability practices, ensuring that they adhere to environmentally responsible recycling practices. R2 certification is a powerful indication that an ITAD company is committed to sustainable practices.

Ultimately, the decision to opt for remarketing vs. buybacks comes down to your organization’s goals and resources. Opt for remarketing to maximize returns on high-value assets, especially if you have adequate internal resources to manage the process and quick cash flow is less important. Choose buybacks if you have a large volume of equipment or older low-value devices. If you want immediate cash flow or internal resources are limited, buybacks are also preferred.

Work with Sturgeon to Hone Your Asset Monetization Strategy

The right asset disposition strategy can help you achieve your organizational goals, whether it’s maximizing financial returns, optimizing operational efficiency, or supporting sustainability initiatives. By aligning your asset disposition strategy with those objectives, you can maximize your company’s resources and help shore up the bottom line.

Remarketing and buybacks complement a broader strategy that minimizes environmental impact while maximizing value. Organizations should create a regular review process to evaluate asset management practices, adapting them as technology evolves or regulatory requirements change.

Sturgeon’s IT asset solutions help support your organization’s strategic decisions for asset disposition. Our expertise in remarketing and buybacks enables you to unlock the full potential of your IT assets while simplifying the process. Contact us today to get started.